RULES, REGULATIONS AND COACHING POINTS - WEEK 8
Illegal formation, the 7 and 4 rule
In the NFL there is an illegal formation penalty, which is penalized 5 yards and repeat the down, and the NFL has made it clear to teams this offseason it will be a point of emphasis this year. To spot an illegal formation can sometimes be really easy, and sometimes with motion involved can happen fast and not so easy to spot. An illegal formation was called in the Dolphins Patriots game and here is the simple explanation to what constitutes ‘illegal’ in the formation.
At the snap of the ball at least seven offensive players need to be on the line of scrimmage and the remaining, up to four players maximum, need to be at least one yard behind the line of scrimmage. So, if you see more than four players eligible to catch a pass at one yard or more back from the line of scrimmage, that is a penalty.
Of the seven players on the line of scrimmage, the two on the ends who are on the line must be eligible receivers and the remaining five between them must wear ineligible numbers. That’s why you see the receiver outside the tight end lining up one yard or so behind the line as it’s the players on the line that count. The quick and easy calculation in that scenario is five offensive linemen wearing ineligible numbers 50-79 or 90-99, a wideout to the opposite side of the tight end who lines up on the line and the tight end to the other side also on the line with the wideout to his side behind the line. It’s the seven and four rule in its simplest.
If in the example above, the wideout to the tight end side steps up to the line, then the tight end is still in a legal position, but becomes ineligible to catch a pass as he is ‘covered’ and makes eight on the line. If that wideout who is lined up behind the line on the tight end side, and the tight end is on the line, goes in motion he must not end up anywhere on the line before the snap. If the other wideout on the opposite side to the tight end is behind the line then the offensive tackle on his side, usually the left tackle, becomes ‘uncovered’ and as an ineligible receiver draws an illegal formation penalty. There are a few more quirks to the illegal formation rule but this is generally the bulk of the penalties called.
When the offensive line gets ready for a pass, if they line up in the ‘bowed’ line formation, the tackles must not line up too far back from the line to line up one yard behind as they are deemed one of the four eligible to catch a pass but would be wearing an ineligible number and that would draw a penalty. The difficulty identifying an illegal formation is when motion, short yardage passing and goal line passing makes the seven to four rule a little murky.
